The Rise of Online Sex Work vs. The Decline of Sex in America

In recent years, the digital landscape has transformed the adult industry, with platforms like OnlyFans leading the charge. OnlyFans is a platform where creators can share exclusive content with their subscribers, mostly this is used for sex workers. As traditional notions of sex work evolve, an interesting paradox is unfolding: while sex work is more accessible than ever, the frequency of sex in America is declining. This shift raises crucial questions about the intersection of technology, intimacy, and societal well-being.

The Online Porn Industry is Booming, Framed as Female Empowerment

The rise of OnlyFans has been largely marketed as an opportunity for creators—predominantly women—to take control of their bodies, finances, and careers. With over 46 million U.S. adults consuming online porn frequently and an estimated 32,497 people watching it at any given moment, the demand for adult content is undeniable. As a result, the industry itself has expanded significantly. By 2023, the online pornography and adult content sector in the U.S. was projected to employ 1,385 people—up 23% from 2018. 

Supporters of the industry argue that it empowers sex workers by eliminating exploitative middlemen and allowing direct interaction with paying subscribers. But behind the glossy social media narratives of financial freedom and empowerment, the reality of OnlyFans earnings tells a different story.

The Reality of OnlyFans Earnings

Worldwide as of 2023, there are more than 2.1 million Onlyfans creators, with the platform paying out over $5bn per year to creators. Despite top earners' success stories, most OnlyFans creators make significantly less than expected. On average, creators earn between $150 and $180 per month—roughly $2,000 per year. After taxes, this amount dwindles further. The income distribution on OnlyFans is heavily skewed, with the top 1% of creators earning about a third of all the money on the platform. 

Meanwhile, the top 10% take home nearly 75% of the platform’s total earnings. This means the vast majority of OnlyFans creators struggle to turn their content into a sustainable income source, despite the platform’s portrayal as a financial game-changer for sex workers.

The Double Standard: Performers vs. Consumers

While online sex workers face societal scrutiny, discrimination, and potential long-term consequences for their digital footprint, those who consume their content remain largely anonymous. The stigma around selling adult content remains high, often resulting in social ostracization, job loss, and difficulties in future career prospects. Meanwhile, frequent consumers of online porn face no such stigma, despite growing evidence of the negative psychological and emotional impacts of excessive porn consumption.

Not to mention the effects it has on long-term mating prospects. On my own Instagram story, I asked people if they would date someone if they knew they had an Only Fans account and then I asked if people would date someone if they knew they watched porn. These were the results. 72% of people said they would not date someone who did porn. 60% said they would date someone who watched porn.

This disparity reflects a broader cultural hypocrisy—one that simultaneously shames individuals for profiting from sex work while normalizing the consumption of the very same content.

Porn is Reinforcing Loneliness—And Branding It as Freedom

While the online adult industry continues to grow, intimacy in the real world is in decline. The average American now has sex 53 times per year—nine times fewer than in the 1990s. Research from the Kinsey Institute suggests a decrease in sexual activity, even among young adults, due to a combination of factors, including increased screen time, mental health struggles, and changing social dynamics.

This shift raises concerns about how online pornography may be reshaping intimacy and connection. While platforms like OnlyFans promote the illusion of personal interaction and companionship, they often deepen isolation by replacing real-world relationships with transactional digital interactions. The growing normalization of parasocial relationships—where fans feel emotionally connected to content creators who do not know they exist—further fuels this cycle of loneliness.

The Bottom Line

The rise of online sex work and the decline of real-world intimacy suggest a society moving toward digital escapism at the cost of genuine human connection. While OnlyFans and similar platforms offer economic opportunities, they also highlight a growing cultural crisis: one where artificial intimacy is thriving while real intimacy declines.

Pornography is increasingly being framed as a tool of liberation, yet its widespread consumption may be contributing to the very loneliness and disconnection it claims to alleviate. As society continues to navigate the digitalization of intimacy, it’s worth questioning whether this shift is truly in our best interest—or if we are simply mistaking isolation for freedom.

Thanks for reading, if you found this interesting, share it with a friend!